Sheila Siegrist-Garten

Helping people is what I do. Before becoming a State Farm Agent, I worked as a paralegal in a local law office and later handled claims for State Farm in Ohio and Kentucky. Those experiences shaped how I approach insurance today—with perspective, care, and an understanding of how coverage decisions affect real families. I now work with people who want a personalized insurance plan to protect what matters most, including Auto Insurance, Home Insurance, Condo Insurance, Renters Insurance, Boat Insurance, Motorcycle Insurance, Jewelry Insurance, and more.

One of the most important parts of my work is helping customers plan for the unexpected through thoughtful Life Insurance and Health Insurance options. Everyone in our office has experienced the loss of a loved one, so we understand firsthand how deeply it can impact a family. That shared experience has shaped the kind of agency we’ve built—one that focuses on protecting not just property, but people.

I’ve spent most of my life in this area, growing up in Erlanger/Elsmere, later living in Edgewood, Ft. Wright, KY, and Liberty Township, Ohio, before returning to Edgewood. Today, I live in Crestview Hills, KY with my husband, Tom. I opened my agency in Ft. Mitchell, Kentucky in 1990, and we proudly serve Northern Kentucky communities like Ft. Mitchell, Villa Hills, Edgewood, Crescent Springs, and Erlanger, along with cities and townships throughout Southwest Ohio. These are the communities I call home, and the people I work with every day.

If it helps to talk things through, a quick meeting can be a simple way to review your current coverage and make sure it still fits where life has taken you. My team and I are always glad to listen, answer questions, and connect when it feels right.